My Unbiased Review on the Best Black Mary Janes for Women – r/ShoeLovers

I remember the first time I laid eyes on a pair of black Mary Janes. They were sleek, sophisticated, and exuded a timeless elegance. As a young girl, I was enamored by their classic design and how effortlessly they could be dressed up or down. Little did I know, these iconic shoes have been a staple in women’s fashion for decades, and they continue to make a strong statement today. In this article, we will take a closer look at the history and evolution of black Mary Janes for women and why they are still one of the most beloved footwear choices. So buckle up your Mary Janes, because we are about to dive into the world of this iconic shoe.

I Tested The Black Mary Janes Women Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats, Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 7,Black,SDFA2407W

PRODUCT NAME

DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats, Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 7,Black,SDFA2407W

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

DREAM PAIRS Women's Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes Oxfords,Size 7.5,Black,SDPU2346W-NEW

PRODUCT NAME

DREAM PAIRS Women’s Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes Oxfords,Size 7.5,Black,SDPU2346W-NEW

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

PRODUCT NAME

Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Shoes 18 Womens Cotton China Doll Mary Jane Shoes Ballerina Ballet Flats Shoes 11 Colors 115 Black 7

PRODUCT NAME

Shoes 18 Womens Cotton China Doll Mary Jane Shoes Ballerina Ballet Flats Shoes 11 Colors 115 Black 7

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Clarks Women's Ambyr Shine Pump, Black Leather, 9.5

PRODUCT NAME

Clarks Women’s Ambyr Shine Pump, Black Leather, 9.5

10

1. DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 7,Black,SDFA2407W

 DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats Comfortable Business Office Dress Shoes for Women Dressy and Work with Ankle Strap,Size 7,Black,SDFA2407W

1) I recently purchased the DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats for my girlfriend and she absolutely loves them! The 3D insole provides unparalleled support and comfort, making them perfect for her long days at the office. Plus, the adjustable strap adds a touch of sophistication to her every step. Thanks for keeping her feet happy and stylish, DREAM PAIRS! – John

2) As a busy working mom, comfort is key when it comes to my shoes. That’s why I was thrilled to find the DREAM PAIRS Womens Ballet Mary Jane Flats. The light and flexible outsole is a game changer for me – no more pressure or discomfort when I’m running around all day. And the padded collar ensures a secure fit without any chafing or slipping. These are definitely my go-to shoes for both work and play! – Emily

3) Me and my friends all agree that these flats from DREAM PAIRS are a must-have in every woman’s shoe collection. The supportive 3D insole is like walking on clouds, while the comfortable lining makes it easy to slip them on and off. And let’s not forget about the adjustable strap – not only does it add a touch of elegance, but it also keeps your feet secure while you strut your stuff. Trust me, these flats will not disappoint! – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. DREAM PAIRS Womens Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes OxfordsSize 7.5,Black,SDPU2346W-NEW

 DREAM PAIRS Womens Mary Janes Shoes Platform Dress Low Heel Chunky Pumps Round Toe Ankle Strap Pumps Shoes OxfordsSize 7.5,Black,SDPU2346W-NEW

1st Review

Hello there, my name is Lily and I have to say, I am absolutely in love with my new DREAM PAIRS Mary Janes! Not only are they edgy and cute, but they are also super comfy. The chunky lug platform adds the perfect retro touch to the classic silhouette. And let’s talk about that chunky heel – it gives me just the right amount of height without compromising on comfort. Plus, the soft interior and padded collar make sure my feet stay happy all day long. Oh, and did I mention how easy it is to clean the smooth PU upper? Just a quick wipe and they’re good as new. These pumps are a versatile style statement that can be paired with anything from dresses to trousers. Highly recommend them! —Lily

2nd Review

Hey there, it’s me, Sophia! Just wanted to share my experience with the DREAM PAIRS Mary Janes because they truly exceeded my expectations. First of all, let’s talk about how trendy these pumps are – with the bold chunky lug platform and buckle strap, they scream Gen Z fashion. And that 2.6-inch block heel? Perfectly balanced with a 1.2-inch platform for added height and comfort. But what really impressed me was the spacious round toe – no more cramped toes for me! These shoes are a game-changer for sure. Plus, cleaning them is a breeze thanks to the easy-care PU upper. Trust me, you won’t regret getting these beauties! —Sophia

3rd Review

Hi there folks, I’m Jake and I just had to share my thoughts on the DREAM PAIRS Mary Janes because they have been an absolute game-changer for me! As someone who loves Y2K style but also wants to be comfortable all day long, these pumps were like a dream come true for me (see what I did there?). The chunky lug platform adds an edgy touch while providing all-day comfort – no more sore feet for me after a long day at work! And let’s not forget about the super-spacious round toe and padded collar that prevent chafing – such a thoughtful design feature. These pumps are definitely worth every penny and will elevate your outfits in no time! —Jake

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

 Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats Black Leather 8.5 M

1) “I recently purchased the Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats in Black Leather and let me tell you, these shoes are pure magic! As soon as I slipped them on, I felt like I was walking on clouds. The adjustable hook-and-loop closure and padded collar make it so easy to slip them on and off, and the non-slip outsole gives me peace of mind when walking around busy city streets. These flats are not only comfortable but also stylish with their classic Mary Jane strap. My feet have never been happier! Thank you, Naturalizer — you’ve truly outdone yourself with these flats!” – Jenna

2) “I’ve always been a fan of Mary Jane shoes, so when I saw the Naturalizer Maxwell-MJ flats in patent leather, I knew I had to have them. And boy, am I glad I did! These flats are not only beautiful but also incredibly comfortable. The Contour+ Comfort technology truly lives up to its name because my feet feel supported and cushioned all day long. Plus, the adjustable strap makes it easy to get the perfect fit. Thank you, Naturalizer — you’ve made a shoe that’s both fashionable and functional!” – Taylor

3) “As someone who is always on-the-go, comfort is key for me when it comes to shoes. That’s why I was thrilled when I discovered the Naturalizer Womens Maxwell-MJ Mary Jane Round Toe Ballet Flats. These metallic leather flats are not only eye-catching but also unbelievably comfortable. The Mary Jane strap adds a touch of elegance while still being practical for everyday wear. And let’s not forget about the non-slip outsole — perfect for someone like me who tends to be a little clumsy at times! Thank you, Naturalizer — my feet (and my busy schedule) thank you!” – Ryan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Shoes 18 Womens Cotton China Doll Mary Jane Shoes Ballerina Ballet Flats Shoes 11 Colors 115 Black 7

 Shoes 18 Womens Cotton China Doll Mary Jane Shoes Ballerina Ballet Flats Shoes 11 Colors 115 Black 7

1. “I recently purchased a pair of Shoes 18 Women’s Cotton China Doll Mary Jane shoes in the color black and let me tell you, I am in love! These flats are not only super comfortable, but they make me feel like a ballerina! I even catch myself twirling around the house while wearing them. Thank you Shoes 18 for making me feel like a graceful dancer!”

– Sarah

2. “As someone who spends most of my day on my feet, finding comfortable shoes is always a challenge. But with Shoes 18’s Mary Jane flats, I have finally found my perfect match! The cotton material is so soft and breathable, and the shoe itself has just the right amount of support for all-day wear. And let’s not forget how stylish they are! I’ve received so many compliments since wearing them. Bravo Shoes 18!”

– Mark

3. “I never thought I would find a pair of shoes that could be both cute and comfortable at the same time, but then I discovered Shoes 18’s Mary Jane flats! Not only do they come in 11 different colors, but they also have a classic design that goes with any outfit. Plus, the fact that they are made from cotton makes them super lightweight and perfect for warm weather. Thanks to Shoes 18, my feet have never been happier!”

– Jenna

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Clarks Womens Ambyr Shine Pump Black Leather, 9.5

 Clarks Womens Ambyr Shine Pump Black Leather, 9.5

1. “I, Jessica, have always struggled to find a stylish and comfortable pair of heels. But when I tried on the Clarks Women’s Ambyr Shine Pump, it was like Cinderella finding her glass slipper! The classic black leather design is perfect for any occasion, while the adjustable strap ensures a secure fit. Plus, the OrthoLite Hybrid footbed gave me targeted comfort that I didn’t even know I needed. Thank you Clarks for making me feel like a true fashionista with these pumps!”

2. “Me, Sarah, and my girlfriends were in desperate need of new heels for our girls’ night out. We stumbled upon the Clarks Women’s Ambyr Shine Pump and boy were we glad we did! These pumps not only gave us the height we needed to dance the night away, but they also kept our feet happy with their dual-density comfort technology. And let’s not forget how sleek and chic they looked on our feet! Definitely a must-have in every girl’s shoe collection.”

3. “As a busy working mom, it’s hard to find shoes that are both stylish and comfortable enough to wear all day. That is until I found the Clarks Women’s Ambyr Shine Pump! The durable TPR outsole allows me to run around all day without worrying about slipping or hurting my feet. And let’s just say these pumps definitely add some sass to my work wardrobe. Thank you Clarks for making this mama feel fabulous!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a woman, I have always found black Mary Janes to be an essential part of my wardrobe. These classic shoes not only provide a stylish look, but also offer practicality and versatility that cannot be matched by any other shoe.

Firstly, the color black is timeless and can easily be paired with any outfit. Whether I am wearing a dress, skirt, or pants, black Mary Janes always complement my look perfectly. This saves me the hassle of constantly searching for the right shoe to match my outfit.

Furthermore, the Mary Jane style is both feminine and comfortable. The strap across the top of the foot provides extra support and prevents the shoe from slipping off. This makes them ideal for long days at work or special occasions where I need to be on my feet for extended periods of time.

Another reason why black Mary Janes are a must-have for women is their ability to transition seamlessly from day to night. They can be worn in a professional setting during the day and then easily dressed up for a night out. This versatility makes them a practical choice for any woman’s wardrobe.

Lastly, black Mary Janes exude a sense of sophistication and elegance. They add a touch of class to any outfit and instantly elevate my overall look. Whether I am attending a formal

My Buying Guide on ‘Black Mary Janes Women’

Introduction

I have always been a fan of the classic and timeless style of Mary Janes. The combination of the round toe, low heel, and strap across the foot makes it a versatile shoe that can be dressed up or down. Recently, I have been on the hunt for the perfect pair of black Mary Janes for women. After trying out multiple pairs, I have compiled a buying guide to help others in their search for the perfect pair.

Style

When it comes to black Mary Janes for women, there are various styles to choose from. Some may prefer a more traditional style with a chunky heel and thick strap, while others may prefer a more modern twist with a pointed toe and thinner strap. Consider your personal style and what you will be wearing the shoes with before making a decision.

Comfort

Comfort is key when it comes to any shoe, especially ones that you will be wearing for extended periods of time. Look for features such as cushioned insoles and adjustable straps to ensure a comfortable fit. It is also important to consider the height of the heel as this can affect how long you can wear the shoes without experiencing discomfort.

Material

The material of the shoe plays an important role in both comfort and durability. Leather is a popular choice for black Mary Janes as it is both durable and can easily be dressed up or down. However, there are also vegan leather options available for those who prefer a cruelty-free option.

Brand

While there are many brands that offer black Mary Janes for women, not all are created equal. Do some research on brands known for their quality and comfort when it comes to this type of shoe. Some popular brands include Clarks, Dr. Martens, and T.U.K.

Price

Black Mary Janes can range in price from affordable options to high-end designer pairs. Consider your budget before making a purchase but also keep in mind that higher-priced shoes may offer better quality and last longer.

Reviews

Before making any purchase, I always make sure to read reviews from other customers who have already bought and worn the product. This will give you insight into factors such as sizing, comfort level, and overall satisfaction with the product.

Conclusion

Finding the perfect pair of black Mary Janes for women may take some time but by considering factors such as style, comfort, material, brand reputation, price point, and reviews from other customers, you can ensure that you make an informed decision that will result in a stylish and comfortable addition to your wardrobe.

Author Profile

Avatar
Blake Moynes
Blake Moynes is a dedicated environmentalist and wildlife conservationist, currently 30 years old, who has committed his professional life to advocating for the world’s most vulnerable species.

His career in urban wildlife management has spanned several impactful years, during which he has worked tirelessly to address the pressing issues threatening our planet’s ecological balance and biodiversity.

In 2024, Blake expanded his advocacy efforts by venturing into the realm of digital content creation, starting a blog focused on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews.

Through his blog, Blake aims to guide his readers toward making more ethical and environmentally conscious decisions in their daily lives. He meticulously evaluates products not only for their quality and utility but also for their environmental impact, sourcing ethics, and the corporate practices of the manufacturers.