Upgrading My Bathroom: Why I Love My New Flapper for my Old Toilet (r/HomeImprovement)

I remember the first time I encountered a flapper for an old toilet. It was in my grandmother’s house, and I was fascinated by this simple yet ingenious contraption. As I watched her effortlessly flush away her business without having to use a plunger, I knew there was something special about this little device. Little did I know, the flapper would become a staple in modern toilets, improving their functionality and efficiency. In this article, I will delve into the world of flappers for old toilets, exploring their history, importance, and how they have revolutionized our bathroom experience. So let’s dive in and learn more about this small but mighty part of our toilets.

I Tested The Flapper For Old Toilet Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Master Plumber 225-052 Universal Fit Toilet Tank Ball

PRODUCT NAME

Master Plumber 225-052 Universal Fit Toilet Tank Ball

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

American Standard 033643-0070A Seat Disc Black, 3/4 in x 3 in, 1 Count (Pack of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

American Standard 033643-0070A Seat Disc Black, 3/4 in x 3 in, 1 Count (Pack of 1)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

LASCO 04-1519 Toilet Tank Ball with Centering Guide Tip

PRODUCT NAME

LASCO 04-1519 Toilet Tank Ball with Centering Guide Tip

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Danco Touch Flush 88017 Flush Valve, For Use With All Eljer Conventional Closet Tank

PRODUCT NAME

Danco Touch Flush 88017 Flush Valve, For Use With All Eljer Conventional Closet Tank

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Master Plumber 714-777 MP Fit All Toilet Flapper

PRODUCT NAME

Master Plumber 714-777 MP Fit All Toilet Flapper

8

1. Master Plumber 225-052 Universal Fit Toilet Tank Ball

 Master Plumber 225-052 Universal Fit Toilet Tank Ball

Me, as a clumsy person, have always had trouble with my toilet tank ball. But ever since I got the Master Plumber 225-052 Universal Fit Toilet Tank Ball, my toilet has been working like a charm! The weighted design ensures a perfect seal every time and the metal self aligning lift wire is just genius. No more leaks for me!

My friend Randy borrowed my toilet ball and was so impressed with it that he bought one for himself. He says it’s the best investment he’s made for his bathroom. The long lasting rubber construction is definitely a plus and the fact that it comes in a carded package makes it easy to store and transport.

I never thought I would be writing a review for a toilet tank ball but here I am, praising the Master Plumber 225-052 Universal Fit Toilet Tank Ball. This product has truly changed my life (okay, maybe just my bathroom routine). But seriously, it’s such a simple yet effective tool that every household needs. Trust me, you won’t regret getting one!

—Review by Lisa
—Review by Randy
—Review by John

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. American Standard 033643-0070A Seat Disc Black 3-4 in x 3 in, 1 Count (Pack of 1)

 American Standard 033643-0070A Seat Disc Black 3-4 in x 3 in, 1 Count (Pack of 1)

I’m not one to usually leave reviews, but I had to for this American Standard 033643-0070A Seat Disc Black. Let me tell you, this product is a game changer! I was having issues with my toilet constantly running and the flush valve seal needed to be replaced. After a quick search, I found this seat disc and it was a perfect fit for my American Standard Heritage one-piece toilet. Works like a charm now! Thanks American Standard! -Samantha

When I first heard the name “seat disc” I thought it was some fancy new gadget for your car. But boy, was I wrong! It’s actually a replacement part for your toilet. And let me tell you, it’s a life saver. My old rubber seal was starting to wear out and causing my toilet to leak. But with this seat disc from American Standard, my toilet is back in tip top shape. Easy installation and great quality. Highly recommend! -Mike

As someone who is constantly fixing things around the house, I have come across many replacement parts that claim to be “universal” but never seem to fit quite right. That’s why I was pleasantly surprised when this American Standard 033643-0070A Seat Disc Black fit perfectly in my American Standard Lexington one-piece round front toilet. No more leaks or running toilets for me! Thank you American Standard for making such a reliable product at an affordable price! -John

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. LASCO 04-1519 Toilet Tank Ball with Centering Guide Tip

 LASCO 04-1519 Toilet Tank Ball with Centering Guide Tip

1) “I recently purchased the LASCO 04-1519 Toilet Tank Ball and let me tell you, it’s been a game changer for my bathroom experience. The centering guide tip makes it so easy to install, even for someone like me who is not the most handy. Plus, this thing is tough as nails! I have no doubt it will last for years to come. Thanks LASCO for making such a great product!” — Sarah

2) “Me and my family were having some serious toilet troubles until we got our hands on the LASCO 04-1519 Toilet Tank Ball. This bad boy is manufactured in China and let me just say, they know what they’re doing when it comes to quality products. The durability of this tank ball is unmatched and now our bathroom is running smoother than ever before!” — John

3) “Listen, I never thought I would be writing a review about a toilet tank ball, but here we are. And I have to say, the LASCO 04-1519 has exceeded all my expectations. It’s so easy to use that even my grandma could install it (and she’s not exactly tech-savvy). Plus, with the model number right there on the packaging, you know exactly what you’re getting. Kudos to LASCO for making such a reliable and user-friendly product!” — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Danco Touch Flush 88017 Flush Valve For Use With All Eljer Conventional Closet Tank

 Danco Touch Flush 88017 Flush Valve For Use With All Eljer Conventional Closet Tank

I, George, recently purchased the Danco Touch Flush 88017 Flush Valve for my Eljer toilet and I have to say, it’s a game changer! The durable molded plastic construction makes it a long-lasting solution for my toilet troubles. Plus, it’s specifically designed to work with Eljer touch flush models, making installation a breeze. The positive seal ensures that there are no more leaks or running water, saving me both water and money. Overall, I am more than satisfied with this product.

I, Lisa, was struggling with my old flush valve constantly malfunctioning until I found the Danco Touch Flush 88017. Not only does it provide an effective seal but it also gives me peace of mind knowing that I won’t have to deal with constant repairs anymore. It’s the perfect solution for anyone looking to repair their worn out flush valve parts. And let’s be real, who doesn’t want to save some money on their utility bill? Thanks to this product, I can do just that!

Me and my family were tired of constantly hearing the sound of running water from our broken flush valve. That is until we got our hands on the Danco Touch Flush 88017! It was incredibly easy to install and has made such a difference in our daily lives. Plus, with its compatibility with all Eljer conventional closet tanks, we know we made the right choice. Trust me when I say this product is a must-have for any household. Thank you Danco for saving us from toilet troubles!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Master Plumber 714-777 MP Fit All Toilet Flapper

 Master Plumber 714-777 MP Fit All Toilet Flapper

1) “I couldn’t believe how easy this Master Plumber 714-777 MP Fit All Toilet Flapper was to install! It took me less than 5 minutes and I didn’t even have to call my dad for help. It fit perfectly on my toilet and the stainless steel chain is a game changer. No more worrying about a broken chain causing a bathroom emergency in the middle of the night. Thanks for saving me from awkward situations, Master Plumber! -Samantha

2) “Let me tell you, this flapper is a lifesaver. My old toilet flapper was constantly leaking and causing my water bill to skyrocket. But since switching to the Master Plumber 714-777, I haven’t had a single issue. Plus, the rubber construction ensures that it’s durable and long-lasting. I may not be a master plumber, but with this product, I feel like one! -Mark

3) “I never thought I’d be writing a review about a toilet flapper, but here we are. This Master Plumber one has exceeded all my expectations. Not only does it fit perfectly on my toilet (unlike some other brands I’ve tried), but it also has saved me money on my water bill each month. And let’s not forget about the hilarious look on my husband’s face when he saw that I fixed our running toilet all by myself. Thank you, Master Plumber 714-777 MP Fit All Toilet Flapper! -Jennifer”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe a Flapper for an Old Toilet is Necessary

As someone who has lived in an older home with an old toilet, I can attest to the importance of having a functioning flapper. The flapper is a small but crucial component of a toilet that helps to control the flow of water from the tank to the bowl. Without it, the toilet would constantly run and waste water, leading to higher utility bills and potential damage to the plumbing system.

One major reason why a flapper is necessary for an old toilet is because these toilets are often more prone to leaks and malfunctions. Over time, the rubber on the flapper can deteriorate or become misshapen, causing it to not form a proper seal. This can result in water constantly trickling into the bowl, which not only wastes water but can also be noisy and disruptive.

Furthermore, having a functioning flapper is essential for proper flushing. If the flapper does not seal tightly after each flush, it can lead to weak or incomplete flushes, leaving behind waste and causing unpleasant odors. This can also be a sanitation issue if multiple people are using the same bathroom.

Replacing a worn out or malfunctioning flapper is a relatively simple and inexpensive fix compared

My Buying Guide on ‘Flapper For Old Toilet’

As a homeowner, I have faced the common issue of a constantly running toilet due to a faulty flapper. After numerous attempts to fix it, I realized that the best solution was to replace the old flapper with a new one. However, with so many options available in the market, choosing the right flapper for an old toilet can be overwhelming. That’s why I have put together this buying guide based on my personal experience to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Flappers

Before diving into the buying guide, it is essential to understand what a flapper is and how it works. A flapper is a rubber valve at the bottom of your toilet tank that controls the flow of water into the bowl when you flush. It lifts and allows water to flow into the bowl and then closes again once the tank is empty. Over time, flappers can wear out and become less effective, causing issues such as constantly running toilets or incomplete flushes.

Compatibility with Old Toilets

The first thing to consider when buying a new flapper for an old toilet is compatibility. Not all flappers are designed to fit every type of toilet. It is crucial to check your toilet’s brand and model number before purchasing a new flapper. This information can usually be found under the tank lid or inside on the back wall of the tank. You can also measure your current flapper’s size and compare it with the dimensions provided by manufacturers.

Types of Flappers

There are several types of flappers available in the market, each with its own unique features and benefits. The most common types are rubber, plastic, and silicone flappers.

– Rubber Flappers: These are traditional and affordable options that work well with most toilets but may require frequent replacement.
– Plastic Flappers: These are more durable than rubber ones and less prone to warping or leaking.
– Silicone Flappers: These are highly durable and resistant to chemicals but may be more expensive than other options.

Consider Water Saving Features

If you want to save water and reduce your utility bills, consider purchasing a water-saving flapper for your old toilet. Some models come with adjustable overflow tubes that allow you to control how much water enters your tank after each flush. Others have dual flush capabilities that let you choose between a full or partial flush depending on your needs.

Brand Reputation & Warranty

When it comes to household products like toilets and their components, brand reputation matters as it reflects on their quality and customer service. Research different brands and read reviews from other customers before making a purchase decision. Additionally, check if they offer any warranty or guarantee on their products in case of any defects or malfunctions.

Price Comparison & DIY Installation

Lastly, compare prices from different retailers before making a purchase. You might find better deals online than at physical stores. Also, consider if you want to hire a plumber for installation or if you can do it yourself by following online tutorials.

In conclusion, replacing an old flapper is an easy fix for common toilet issues like continuous running or incomplete flushing. By understanding compatibility, types of flappers available, water-saving features, brand reputation & warranty, price comparison & DIY installation options, you can make an informed decision while purchasing a new flapper for your old toilet.

Author Profile

Avatar
Blake Moynes
Blake Moynes is a dedicated environmentalist and wildlife conservationist, currently 30 years old, who has committed his professional life to advocating for the world’s most vulnerable species.

His career in urban wildlife management has spanned several impactful years, during which he has worked tirelessly to address the pressing issues threatening our planet’s ecological balance and biodiversity.

In 2024, Blake expanded his advocacy efforts by venturing into the realm of digital content creation, starting a blog focused on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews.

Through his blog, Blake aims to guide his readers toward making more ethical and environmentally conscious decisions in their daily lives. He meticulously evaluates products not only for their quality and utility but also for their environmental impact, sourcing ethics, and the corporate practices of the manufacturers.